What If the Other Driver Lies to Insurance After a Chicago Car Crash?

This page has been written, edited, and reviewed by a team of legal writers following our comprehensive editorial guidelines. This page was approved by Founder, Joseph Conboy who has years of legal experience. Our last modified date shows when this page was last reviewed.

Last updated on: January 21, 2026

Joseph Conboy | January 21, 2026

What if the other driver lies to insurance after a Chicago car crash is a real concern for many injured people. A car accident is stressful, and false statements can make it harder to get an insurance claim approved. When the other driver changes their story, blames you, or hides facts from the insurance company, your medical bills and lost wages may be delayed or denied.

Conboy Law helps Chicago drivers protect their rights when an at-fault driver lies after an accident. Our Chicago car accident attorney helps gather evidence, reviews police reports, and handles the other driver’s insurance company after a crash.

Is It Common for Drivers to Lie After a Car Accident?

Yes, it is common for drivers to lie after a car accident, especially when they fear higher insurance rates or legal consequences. Some Chicago drivers change details about how the accident happened to avoid paying for vehicle damage or injuries.

Lying may involve small changes or complete false statements, but even minor lies can affect how insurance adjusters determine fault and handle the insurance claim.

Why Drivers Misrepresent the Facts

Drivers may lie to save money, protect their driving record, or avoid traffic violations. Some fear rising insurance premiums or insurance rates if they are blamed. Others panic at the accident scene and give a false story to avoid paying out of their own pocket.

Common Types of Insurance Lies

  • Blaming the other party: Saying the other driver caused the accident
  • Changing the driver’s story: Altering events leading up to the crash
  • Denying injuries: Claiming injured victims were not hurt
  • Hiding traffic violations: Ignoring red lights or traffic signs
  • False damage claims: Lying about vehicle damage

How Lying to Insurance Affects a Chicago Car Accident Claim

When a driver lies, the insurance company may delay or deny the claim. False statements can slow investigations and increase disputes. This can affect settlement offers and make it harder to recover damages.

Delayed or Denied Insurance Claims

If the at-fault driver lied, the insurance provider may question all accident details. This can lead to denied claims or long delays while insurance adjusters review more evidence.

During this time, injured victims may struggle to pay medical bills, vehicle repairs, or other accident costs. These delays can cause stress and force people to pay out of pocket while waiting for a decision.

Bad Faith and Insurance Disputes

Sometimes an insurance company denies valid claims in bad faith. This happens when insurers ignore evidence or unfairly side with the other driver’s story. They may delay responses, refuse to explain decisions, or pressure victims to accept a low settlement offer. Bad-faith actions can make it harder for injured people to recover damages they deserve.

Illinois Law on Fault and False Statements

Illinois law controls how fault is decided after a Chicago car accident. False statements can impact fault decisions and insurance coverage.

Illinois Is a Fault-Based State

Illinois law follows a fault-based system. The at-fault driver is responsible for paying damages through their driver’s insurance company.

Comparative Negligence Rule

This rule is governed by 735 ILCS 5/2-1116. Compensation is reduced by your share of fault. You recover nothing if you are 50% or more at fault.

How Insurance Companies Investigate Conflicting Stories

Insurance companies investigate when stories conflict. They look for accurate information to decide fault.

Adjuster Reviews and Recorded Statements

Insurance adjusters collect recorded statements and compare each driver’s account. Any red flags can affect the insurance claim. Adjusters listen closely for changes in the driver’s story or details that do not match the accident report.

Even small mistakes in a recorded statement can be used by the insurance company to question fault or deny payment.

Use of Physical and Digital Evidence

Police reports, traffic camera footage, medical records, and witness statements are critical evidence. More evidence helps prove what really happened. Photos from the accident scene and vehicle damage can clearly show how the crash occurred.

Digital records and written proof often carry more weight than spoken statements when insurance companies review claims.

What If the Other Driver Files a False Claim Against You?

A false claim can put you at risk of paying damages. Quick action helps protect your best interests.

Defending Against False Accusations

Gather as much evidence as possible, including witness info and photos. Police reports from the Chicago Police Department help show the truth. Medical records can also support your own account by showing when and how injuries were treated. Keeping clear notes about what happened helps protect you if the other party continues to make false statements.

Using Your Own Insurance Coverage

Your own auto insurance policy may provide coverage. Your insurance provider can help defend against false statements. This coverage may help pay for medical bills, vehicle damage, or legal costs while the claim is reviewed. Reporting the accident early helps your insurance company act faster and protect your interests.

Can Lying to Insurance Be Illegal in Illinois?

Yes, lying to insurance can be illegal in Illinois. It may lead to serious legal consequences.

Insurance Fraud Consequences

Insurance fraud can result in fines, loss of coverage, or jail time in the worst-case scenario. A driver may also face long-term problems with insurance rates and future coverage. These legal consequences can follow a person for years, affecting their driving record and their ability to get car insurance.

Difference Between Criminal Fraud and Civil Liability

Criminal cases involve punishment, while civil cases focus on who must pay damages for injuries or property damage. A criminal case is handled by the state and may lead to fines or jail time. A civil case focuses on helping injured people recover money for medical bills, lost wages, and other losses.

When to Involve a Chicago Car Accident Lawyer

Legal help matters when lies affect your case. A lawyer helps protect your legal options.

Challenging False Statements and Denials

A Chicago car accident lawyer challenges false statements and unfair denials using strong proof. This includes comparing the driver’s story with police reports, witness statements, and accident details. When lies are exposed, it becomes harder for the insurance company to deny a valid claim.

Building a Strong Evidence-Based Claim

A personal injury attorney gathers witness information, medical attention records, and accident reports to support your claim. This evidence helps show how the accident happened and who was at fault. Strong proof also makes it easier to recover damages for injuries and losses.

Protecting You From Bad Faith Insurance Tactics

An experienced car accident attorney pushes back when insurance companies shift blame or delay payment. Legal help forces insurers to follow the rules and act fairly. This protection helps prevent low settlement offers that do not cover your real losses.

Preparing for Litigation If the Claim Is Denied

If needed, a personal injury lawsuit may be filed to recover damages and seek compensation. Filing a lawsuit shows the insurance company you are serious about your claim. It also allows a court to review the evidence and decide what is fair.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Should I call the police immediately after a crash?

Yes, police immediately create an official accident report.

Can lies affect my settlement offer?

Yes, false statements can lower or delay settlement offers.

What if the other party keeps lying?

Legal help can stop false claims and protect your car accident case.

Should I report the crash to the police or the insurance company first?

You should report the crash to the police or insurance company as soon as possible to protect your claim.

Why is immediate medical attention important after a crash?

Immediate medical attention creates records that help prove injuries and protect your claim with the other driver’s insurance company.

Contact Our Chicago Car Accident Attorney for a Free Consultation

If you believe the other driver lied to insurance after a Chicago car accident, help is available. Conboy Law understands how insurance companies work and how false statements affect claims. We help injured victims gather evidence, deal with insurance adjusters, and seek compensation for medical bills, lost wages, and property damage.

Our Chicago car accident attorney will explain your rights, review police reports, and guide you through the process. Contact us today for a free consultation and learn how we help protect you and your claim.

Joseph Conboy
Founding Attorney

Joseph M. Conboy, founder of Conboy Law, represents victims of catastrophic injuries and wrongful death, securing numerous multi-million-dollar results. Recognized as a Super Lawyers Rising Star (2019–2022), he is a member of the American Association for Justice and Illinois Trial Lawyers Association. Mr. Conboy earned his J.D. from DePaul University and a B.A. in Economics from the University of Colorado.

Thanks to this amazing law firm, I was able to successfully bring justice and get the help I needed. They really care a lot about their clients, they’re 100 percent fully involved in your case and will do the most to make sure you get the help you need. Thanks for everything!
Tiffany H.
I can't say enough about Joseph Conboy. He was a true asset during our personal injury claim and had such an amazing legal approach, which made me feel like his top priority from day one! I'm so grateful we were able to work together for this win/win outcome.
Jackson K.
Our Location
Available to take your call 24/7
Request a FREE Consultation

Name(Required)
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
It's not just a case,
it's your life.
Request your free consultation

If you or a loved one has been injured, don’t hesitate to contact our injury attorneys today!

"*" indicates required fields

Name*
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.