Wrong Site Surgeries

Wrong Site Surgeries

Joseph Conboy | June 6, 2025 | Medical Malpractice

Conboy Law Injury & Medical Malpractice Lawyers helps victims of wrong site surgeries fight for justice. We understand how frustrating and painful it is when a mistake like this causes unnecessary suffering. Our legal team works with medical experts and reviews detailed medical records to determine what went wrong and how to hold the health care providers accountable.

If you or a loved one has been affected, we are here to help you take the right steps forward.

What Is a Wrong Site Surgery?

A wrong site surgery happens when a surgical procedure is performed on the wrong part of the body, the wrong side, or even the wrong patient. This includes wrong person surgery, wrong procedure, and operations on the wrong side of the body or wrong part altogether. These errors are part of a larger group of sentinel events, which are serious mistakes that should never occur in a hospital.

These mistakes are preventable. That’s why national health agencies, including the Joint Commission, have introduced the Universal Protocol and National Patient Safety Goals to lower these risks. These protocols include a pre-surgery “time out,” which is a pause before every surgery to confirm the correct patient, correct procedure, and correct surgical site.

Even with these rules in place, errors still happen due to missed steps, rushed communication, or failure to follow key elements of safety procedures.

Types of Wrong Site Surgeries

Wrong site surgeries come in several forms, all of which are serious and often life-changing for the patient. These include:

  • Wrong Side Surgery: This is when the procedure is performed on the incorrect side of the body. For example, operating on the left knee instead of the right. These errors happen when the surgical team fails to verify the procedure site during the time out or prep process.
  • Wrong Procedure: In this situation, the surgeon performs the incorrect operation altogether. A patient might go in for a minor procedure and end up receiving a more invasive or unrelated one. This is a breakdown in communication about the correct surgery and reflects failure to follow the universal protocol.
  • Wrong Patient: This is an extremely rare but devastating event where the surgery performed is meant for someone else entirely. This often happens due to misidentification during pre-surgery steps, especially in fast-paced or overcrowded hospitals that lack proper ID confirmation.
  • Wrong Body Part or Site: Sometimes the surgical procedure is done on the wrong body part such as the wrong finger, eye, or even organ. This may be due to unclear medical records, labeling errors, or failure to mark the procedure site properly.
  • Wrong Person Surgery or Procedure: Also known as procedure wrong person surgery, this occurs when the planned treatment is mistakenly done on a different patient, often because of mix-ups in scheduling, charting, or room assignments. These types of medical errors are classified as never events, errors that should never happen.

Each of these errors not only violates the Joint Commission’s Universal Protocol for Preventing Wrong Site, Wrong Procedure, Wrong Person Surgery, but they also put the patient’s safety at serious risk and often lead to additional procedures, complications, and significant harm.

How Do Wrong Site Surgeries Happen?

How Do Wrong Site Surgeries Happen?

Wrong site surgeries do not occur randomly. These serious events often happen because of breakdowns in communication, missed safety checks, or failure to follow proven protocols. When healthcare organizations rush or skip steps, even experienced teams can make dangerous mistakes.

These situations are preventable when all members of the surgical team follow each key safety step properly.

What Are the Common Causes of Wrong Site Surgeries?

Several causes contribute to these errors:

  • Failure to Follow Universal Protocol: The Joint Commission’s Universal Protocol requires steps like pre-procedure verification, marking the surgical site, and taking a mandatory time out before surgery begins. Skipping these can result in wrong person, wrong procedure, or wrong body part surgeries.
  • Miscommunication Among Staff: A surgeon, nurse, or perioperative registered nurse might mishear or misunderstand what procedure is planned. These contributing factors increase the risk of wrong-site errors.
  • Incomplete or Inaccurate Medical Records: If medical errors exist in the patient’s chart or the records don’t clearly identify the correct patient and correct surgery, it’s easier to confuse procedures.
  • Lack of Site Marking or Inconsistent Marking Practices: In many wrong surgical procedure cases, the body part or side was never marked at all. Or the marking was unclear or erased during prep.
  • Inadequate Training or Oversight: In busy hospitals or with newer health care providers, failure to understand key elements of safe surgery planning can lead to catastrophic results.
  • Rushed Procedures or Emergency Situations: In fast-moving environments, especially in ambulatory care or when treating multiple patients quickly, staff may not double-check important details. This makes the process more vulnerable to mistakes.

Each of these failures can cause an adverse event, and that’s why the prevention of wrong site surgeries depends on strong teamwork, full staff participation, and zero shortcuts.

Are Wrong Site Surgeries Considered Medical Malpractice?

Yes, wrong site surgeries are usually considered medical malpractice. This means the doctor or hospital made a serious mistake that should not have happened. These mistakes often break safety rules that all medical workers are supposed to follow.

Legal Perspective

When a wrong site surgery happens, it means a doctor operated on the wrong body part, the wrong person, or did the wrong procedure. That is not just a mistake, but it’s a serious event that shows something went very wrong. In most cases, the healthcare provider breached their duty. This breach is what makes it medical malpractice.

If a patient gets hurt because of this kind of mistake, they may have a right to file a medical malpractice claim. The goal of the claim is to get help with medical bills, lost time from work, pain, and other problems the mistake caused.

Proving a Medical Malpractice Case

To prove medical malpractice, your lawyer has to show:

  • The doctor or medical team had a duty to treat you safely.
  • They broke that duty by doing the wrong surgery.
  • You suffered harm because of that mistake.
  • The harm led to medical bills, pain, or other losses.

In many malpractice cases, lawyers also use medical records, expert doctors, and hospital rules to show what went wrong. These tools help prove that the mistake could have been prevented and that the patient deserves help.

What Are the Consequences of Wrong Site Surgeries?

What Are the Consequences of Wrong Site Surgeries?

When doctors do surgery on the wrong part of the body, it can cause big problems. These surgeries can hurt the body, the mind, and a person’s ability to live a normal life. Some people never fully heal. Others need more surgeries just to fix what went wrong. Many of these mistakes could have been stopped by following simple safety steps.

Physical Impact

When a doctor performs surgery on the wrong part of your body, it can lead to very painful and serious physical problems. For example, if a healthy leg is operated on by mistake, you may lose the ability to walk normally ever again. You might need another surgery to fix what went wrong, and even then, the damage may not fully heal.

Some people live with constant pain, limited movement, or even complete loss of a body part. These are not just small problems, they can change how you live your life every day. It may become hard to work, drive, play with your kids, or even do simple things like getting dressed. These physical effects are long-lasting and often permanent.

Emotional & Psychological Harm

The emotional harm from a wrong site surgery can be just as bad (or even worse) than the physical harm. People who go through these mistakes often feel scared, angry, or deeply sad. They may lose trust in doctors and hospitals.

Some people cannot sleep well or start to avoid medical care altogether because they are too afraid of something going wrong again. These feelings of fear, stress, and worry can affect every part of a person’s life. A mistake like this may also lead to depression or anxiety that needs counseling or treatment.

Living with a body that was harmed by mistake can cause someone to feel embarrassed or ashamed, which adds even more stress.

Financial Costs

The cost of fixing a surgery that was done on the wrong body part can be extremely high. You may have to pay for more doctor visits, more surgeries, and longer hospital stays. You might need physical therapy, new medications, or even medical tools like crutches or wheelchairs.

Many people have to take time off work, and some can’t return to their jobs at all. That means less money for your bills and your family. If you were the main person working in your home, this could be very hard on everyone.

You may also have trouble getting your insurance to pay for all of this, especially if the mistake was not clearly reported. All of this adds up and can cause a lot of financial stress and debt.

FAQs

Many hospitals and health care professionals are working hard on preventing wrong site surgery before it can ever happen. They follow safety steps like taking a “time out” in the operating room to double-check everything before they begin. They also use tools from the Joint Commission accreditation manual to help teams follow strict safety rules. Groups like the American Hospital Association and risk managers are also helping hospitals develop strategies that lower the chance of mistakes. These steps are all part of building a safer health system where patients are better protected.

Even when doctors try to be careful, wrong surgeries can still happen due to several risk factors. Sometimes, procedures performed are rushed or staff are too busy. Other times, there’s poor communication between professional disciplines, or the markings on the patient’s body are unclear. A lack of a final check, distractions in the operating room, or confusion between patients with similar names can lead to errors. Root cause analysis is used afterward to find out what exactly went wrong and how to stop it from happening again.

There are many experts who help make sure hospitals follow the rules. The Joint Commission, which gives hospitals their official approval, looks closely at how they follow safety steps. They also create tools like the universal protocol to stop these types of mistakes. In addition, healthcare research teams and quality improvement experts track how well hospitals are doing. Risk managers inside the hospitals also work daily to check systems and watch for problems. Everyone works together to reduce medical errors and create a system patients can trust.

Some relevant clinical specialties may be more at risk. For example, orthopedic surgeons often work on arms, legs, knees, and other body parts that may look similar. This is why health care professionals in these fields must be extra careful. Everyone in the room, from nurses to doctors, must clearly confirm the correct patient, correct surgery, and correct side or body part before doing anything. These checks are part of the key steps used to avoid confusion during every invasive procedure.

If surgery was done on the wrong eye or another wrong body part, it’s often seen as a very serious mistake. These are called “never events” because they should never happen. The medicine report from top medical groups says this type of mistake can cause lasting harm. If it happens to you, talk to a lawyer right away. You may be able to file a legal claim and seek compensation for the damage caused. A good legal team can help you understand your rights and what steps to take next.

Contact Our Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer for a Free Case Review

Contact Our Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer for a Free Case Review

If you or a loved one had surgery done on the wrong site, or suffered harm during a procedure performed on the wrong body part, you may have a legal case. These types of mistakes often happen when safety steps are missed or skipped. Conboy Law Injury & Medical Malpractice Lawyers understands how deeply these errors can affect your life. Our team takes the time to listen, review your medical records, and investigate what went wrong during your invasive procedure.

Whether your case involves a wrong eye, wrong patient, or failure to follow the universal protocol, we are here to help. We know how to work with medical experts, study risk factors, and build strong cases based on healthcare research and facts. We are here to help you hold the responsible parties accountable and push for the fair compensation you deserve.

Contact us today for a free case review. You won’t pay unless we win for you.

Conboy Law - Chicago, IL

Address: 60 W Randolph St. 4th Floor Chicago, IL 60601

It's not just a case,
it's your life.
Request your free consultation

If you or a loved one has been injured, don’t hesitate to contact our injury attorneys today!

"*" indicates required fields

Name*
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.