What Is a Medical Negligence Claim?

Winning a medical malpractice case depends on showing that a doctor, nurse, or hospital failed to meet the standard of care. Not all negative outcomes qualify as negligence. A lawyer can help determine if the harm suffered is considered medical negligence under the law.

Defining a Medical Negligence Claim

A medical negligence claim happens when a healthcare professional makes a mistake that causes harm. This can include errors in diagnosis, surgery, medication, or other types of medical treatment. For a claim to be valid, the mistake must go beyond a simple error and show a failure to meet professional standards.

Not all poor outcomes in medical care qualify as negligence. Some treatments have risks, and complications can happen even when doctors follow proper procedures. A medical provider is only liable if they acted carelessly or made a mistake that another qualified professional would not have made in the same situation.

Winning a medical malpractice lawsuit requires proving four elements: the provider had a duty of care, they failed to meet that duty, the mistake directly caused harm, and the patient suffered damages. Without these, a claim may not succeed in court.

Difference Between Medical Negligence and Medical Malpractice

Medical Negligence	Medical Malpractice
A healthcare professional makes an unintentional mistake.	A medical provider knowingly fails to provide proper care.
The provider’s action or inaction causes harm.	The provider is aware of the risk but does not take proper precautions.
Example: A doctor misreads medical records and prescribes the wrong medication.	Example: A surgeon operates on the wrong body part despite correct instructions.
May not always result in a medical malpractice lawsuit.	Usually leads to a formal legal claim against the provider.
The mistake is considered medical negligence if it could have been avoided through reasonable care.	The mistake involves reckless behavior or ignoring accepted medical care standards.

Common Examples of Medical Negligence

Some of the most common medical negligence cases involve:

Diagnostic Errors

Misdiagnosis and delayed diagnosis are leading causes of medical malpractice cases. If a healthcare professional fails to recognize a condition or diagnoses the wrong illness, the patient may receive incorrect or delayed treatment.

For example, a doctor may mistake a heart attack for acid reflux, leading to life-threatening consequences. If a patient with cancer is misdiagnosed and does not receive treatment in time, their condition may worsen. A medical provider can be held liable if a misdiagnosis causes harm that could have been prevented.

Surgical Mistakes

Surgical errors can have devastating consequences. A surgeon may operate on the wrong body part, leave instruments inside a patient, or make a mistake that leads to excessive bleeding or infection. Errors can also happen before or after surgery.

If a medical practitioner fails to obtain informed consent, does not properly monitor a patient, or administers incorrect anesthesia, they may be held responsible. Some surgical mistakes result from poor communication, fatigue, or failure to follow protocols.

Hospitals must ensure that other medical professionals involved in surgery, such as anesthesiologists and nurses, follow safety procedures. When mistakes happen, both the doctor and the hospital may face medical malpractice liability.

Medication and Prescription Errors

Mistakes with medication are common in medical malpractice lawsuits. Patients can suffer severe harm if they receive the wrong prescription, incorrect dosage, or a drug that interacts dangerously with another medication.

A doctor may prescribe the wrong drug because they misread medical records or confuse a patient’s symptoms. A pharmacist may fill a prescription incorrectly. Nurses in hospitals may administer the wrong dosage, leading to dangerous side effects or overdose.

When a healthcare provider fails to check a patient’s history or ignores potential risks, they can be held liable. Patients depend on doctors and pharmacists to ensure safe medical care, and errors can have life-threatening results.

Birth Injuries and Pregnancy Negligence

Negligence during pregnancy, labor, or delivery can cause lifelong injuries to a baby or mother. Medical malpractice claims often arise when doctors fail to monitor fetal distress, perform a necessary C-section, or use excessive force during birth.

Birth injuries can include brain damage, nerve damage, or fractures caused by improper delivery techniques. A doctor may also prescribe unsafe medications during pregnancy, leading to birth defects. If a baby does not receive enough oxygen during birth due to a medical provider’s mistake, they may suffer permanent damage.

Hospitals and medical professionals must provide proper prenatal care and respond quickly to complications. When they fail to do so, families may have grounds for a medical negligence lawsuit.

Hospital and Nursing Errors

Hospitals must ensure that medical professionals provide safe, effective care. If a hospital is understaffed or fails to train its employees, it may be responsible for malpractice claims. Negligence in hospitals can include failure to monitor patients, unsanitary conditions, or improper handling of medical equipment.

Nurses who do not follow doctor’s orders or fail to report symptoms may also contribute to medical malpractice cases. If a patient develops an infection due to unclean conditions or does not receive proper post-surgical care, the hospital may be held liable. In some cases, both individual doctors and the hospital can face legal action.

Elements of a Medical Negligence Claim

Mistakes in medical treatment happen, but not all errors are considered medical negligence. The law only holds medical providers responsible if they fail to follow proper medical standards.

To win a medical negligence lawsuit, a patient must prove four things. These elements are:

Duty of Care

A healthcare professional must provide care that meets accepted medical standards. When a patient sees a doctor, that doctor takes responsibility for their treatment. Hospitals, nurses, and other medical professionals also have a duty to provide safe care. If a medical provider accepts a patient but does not follow standard practices, they may be responsible for any harm caused.

Breach of Duty

A breach of duty happens when a medical practitioner fails to meet professional standards. This means they made a mistake that another qualified doctor would not have made. For example, if a doctor ignores test results, misdiagnoses a condition, or prescribes the wrong drug, they may have breached their duty.

If a nurse does not follow instructions or makes a serious mistake during surgery, they may also be at fault. Proving a breach often requires expert testimony. Medical malpractice cases rely on medical professionals to explain what went wrong.

Causation

A patient must show that the medical provider’s mistake directly caused harm. It is not enough to prove that the doctor made an error. The patient must prove that they were hurt because of it. For example, if a doctor misdiagnoses cancer but the delay in treatment does not worsen the patient’s condition, there may not be grounds for a case. But if a misdiagnosis caused serious harm, such as delayed surgery or worsening symptoms, the doctor may be responsible.

Causation can be hard to prove. Insurance companies and hospitals often argue that the patient’s condition was already serious, not made worse by the mistake. A lawyer gathers medical records and expert opinions to prove the connection.

Damages

Damages refer to the losses a patient suffers because of medical malpractice. These can be financial, physical, or emotional. Financial losses include medical expenses, lost wages, and ongoing care. Physical damages include pain, disability, or worsening health conditions. Emotional damages include anxiety, trauma, or depression caused by medical mistakes.

Without proof of damages, a medical malpractice lawsuit may not succeed. Even if a doctor makes a mistake, the patient must show how it harmed them. Medical malpractice attorneys help victims calculate their damages and fight for fair compensation.

How to File a Medical Negligence Claim

Gathering Evidence

Evidence is the most important part of a medical malpractice lawsuit. Patients must prove that a medical provider made a mistake that caused harm. Strong evidence makes it harder for hospitals and insurance companies to deny responsibility.

Key evidence includes medical records, test results, prescriptions, and doctor’s notes. These documents show what treatment was given and whether the doctor followed standard procedures. Patients should also keep records of symptoms, medical bills, and any changes in their health.

Expert opinions are often needed to prove negligence. A healthcare professional can review the case and confirm that a serious mistake was made. Without expert testimony, winning a case is difficult.

Consulting a Medical Negligence Lawyer

A medical malpractice attorney is essential for handling a claim. These cases require knowledge of medical law, court procedures, and how to deal with insurance companies. A lawyer will review the medical records, consult experts, and determine if the case is strong enough to proceed. They also handle paperwork, negotiate settlements, and represent clients in court.

Having a skilled lawyer increases the chances of a favorable outcome. Without legal help, hospitals and insurance companies may try to avoid settlement payments or deny responsibility. A lawyer fights to make sure victims get the compensation they deserve.

Filing the Claim

Once enough evidence is collected, the lawyer files the claim. This starts the legal proceedings against the doctor, hospital, or other medical professionals responsible for the mistake. The defendant will have a chance to respond, and both sides will present their case.

Many medical malpractice cases settle before trial, but if no agreement is reached, the case goes to court. Filing deadlines vary by state. If a claim is not filed in time, the patient may lose their right to seek compensation. A lawyer ensures all deadlines are met and the case moves forward properly.

Compensation in a Medical Negligence Case

Victims of medical malpractice may receive compensation for financial losses, pain, and suffering. The amount depends on the severity of the harm, the cost of medical treatment, and the impact on the patient’s life.

Compensation falls into the following three categories:

Economic Damages

Economic damages cover financial losses caused by medical negligence. This includes past and future medical expenses, lost income, and ongoing care.

Patients may recover costs for hospital stays, surgeries, medications, and physical therapy. If the injury prevents the patient from working, they may also receive compensation for lost wages. Some victims require long-term care, such as home nursing or rehabilitation, which increases the claim’s value.

Economic damages are easier to calculate because they involve actual expenses. Medical records, bills, and income statements help prove the amount owed to the patient.

Non-Economic Damages

Non-economic damages compensate for pain, suffering, and emotional distress caused by medical malpractice. These damages are more difficult to measure since they do not involve financial losses.

Patients may experience anxiety, depression, or loss of enjoyment of life after a medical malpractice case. Some suffer permanent disabilities or disfigurement, affecting their daily lives. In cases of extreme suffering, courts may award significant compensation.

The value of non-economic damages depends on the severity of the injury. Judges and juries consider how much the patient’s life has changed due to the mistake.

Punitive Damages (In Extreme Cases)

Punitive damages punish healthcare professionals for extreme negligence or intentional wrongdoing. These are only awarded in rare cases where the provider acted recklessly or with deliberate disregard for patient safety.

For example, if a medical provider knowingly used unsafe practices or ignored a life-threatening condition, the court may award punitive damages. These payments serve as a warning to prevent similar mistakes in the healthcare industry.

Punitive damages are not common in medical malpractice claims, but when awarded, they can be substantial. They are meant to hold doctors and hospitals accountable for serious violations of patient safety.

Challenges in Proving a Medical Negligence Claim

Many patients do not have the knowledge to explain medical errors. Courts rely on medical professionals to testify and confirm if a mistake was made. Without expert testimony, proving negligence is difficult.

Doctors and hospitals may argue that the injury was caused by an existing condition not by a mistake. A lawyer helps collect the right evidence to prove otherwise.

Defenses Used by Healthcare Providers

Hospitals and doctors use many defenses in medical malpractice lawsuits. They may claim the injury was unavoidable or that the medical provider followed standard procedures. Some providers argue that the patient’s condition was already serious and would not have improved with different care.

Others may say that the patient accepted the risks of the treatment. To fight these defenses, a lawyer must show clear proof that the healthcare professional made an avoidable mistake. Strong evidence and expert opinions help overcome these arguments.

Statute of Limitations for Medical Negligence Claims in Illinois

In Illinois, patients must file a medical negligence lawsuit within two years from the date they knew or should have known about the injury. This rule applies to most medical malpractice cases. If the claim is not filed in time, the patient loses the right to seek compensation.

There is also a four-year deadline from the date the mistake happened. This means even if a patient discovers the harm later, they cannot file a claim if more than four years have passed. For minors, Illinois law allows more time. If the victim was under 18 years old, they have until their 22nd birthday to file a claim.

If a doctor or hospital hides the mistake, the deadline may be extended. However, Illinois does not allow any claims after eight years, even if the error was undiscovered. A medical malpractice attorney can help ensure the claim is filed on time.

FAQs

Contact Our Chicago Medical Malpractice Lawyer Today

We offer a free consultation to review your case. There are no upfront costs, and you pay nothing unless we win. Contact us today to speak with a lawyer who will protect your rights and guide you through the legal process.